NutmegSpiced is a Grenadian-owned bakery in Toronto, built on memory, craftsmanship, and the comforting flavours of the Caribbean.

Founded by culinary-trained chef and recipe developer Sonisha Paul, NutmegSpiced began with three toaster ovens in a commercial kitchen and a desire to recreate the warm, fuzzy feeling of home through food. What started as a small passion project has grown into a beloved walk-up bakery window known for handcrafted pastries, small-batch desserts, and original Caribbean-inspired creations.

Every recipe at NutmegSpiced is developed in-house with intention, care, and deep respect for traditional Caribbean baking. From our signature Cut Cake and buttery Currant Rolls to our Black Rum Cake, Caribbean Bread Pudding, Coconut Tarts, and gourmet brown butter cookies, each item is made to deliver bold flavour, nostalgia, and comfort in every bite.

We proudly use real ingredients, freshly processed coconut, premium butter, spices, and authentic Caribbean flavours sourced from local suppliers and the Island of Spice, Grenada. Unlike mass-produced baking, our products are made in small batches to preserve quality, freshness, and the integrity of every recipe.

NutmegSpiced is more than a bakery — it is a modern interpretation of Caribbean baking culture. Our approach blends tradition with innovation, creating pastries and desserts that feel both nostalgic and elevated. Whether through our seasonal collections, handcrafted pastries, or carefully curated gift boxes, we aim to create experiences that feel thoughtful, memorable, and deeply personal.

Today, customers travel from across Toronto and beyond for a taste of NutmegSpiced. What continues to set us apart is not only the quality of our products, but the heart behind them — the late nights, the years of recipe development, the commitment to doing things properly, and the belief that food has the power to reconnect people to memories, family, and home.

Whether you’re visiting our bakery window on Oakwood Avenue or ordering from across Canada, we hope every treat reminds you to slow down, savour the moment, and experience a little piece of the Caribbean.

NutmegSpiced — born from memories, baked with love.